Politics Live

This week we checked a claim from the Scottish National Party’s (SNP) Europe spokesperson, Alyn Smith MP. 

On 5 February he said: “The SNP remains the only party committed to rejoining the EU and the world’s largest single market”. 

But this isn’t the case. Other political parties, such as Plaid Cymru, Alliance and the Green Party, all support rejoining the EU. The Liberal Democrats and the Scottish Liberal Democrats say rejoining the EU is their “longer-term objective”.

Read our full fact check to learn more.

A video clip shared on social media, including by the Conservative party and the Reclaim party leader Laurence Fox, appears to show the Mayor of London Sadiq Khan describing the Labour party as “antisemitic”. But this is misleading—the clip is a shortened version of an interview with Mr Khan, and fails to show him correcting himself seconds later. 

During the interview with Sky News earlier on Thursday, Mr Khan was discussing the suspension of two Labour parliamentary candidates due to comments they allegedly made about Israel. 

In the full version of the clip, he said: "As far as I'm concerned, that sort of language isn’t acceptable and it certainly shouldn't be acceptable in a party like mine, that is proud to be both anti-racist but also antisemitic."

Quickly realising he had misspoken, Mr Khan immediately corrected himself, saying: "I beg your pardon, tackling antisemitism." 

However, the shorter version of the clip being shared cuts off before Mr Khan makes the correction. The edited clip was posted by the Conservatives along with the message: “Sadiq Khan says the quiet part out loud.”

We’ve contacted the Conservative and Reclaim parties for comment.

Political parties should ensure claims they make are accurate and include all necessary context—and this includes when representing the speech of other politicians.

On BBC’s Sunday with Laura Kuenssberg last weekend, housing campaigner Kwajo Tweneboa said “We know the majority of people now in the UK are renting”.

However, this doesn’t seem to be the case. 

The majority of households own their home. The government’s annual housing survey for England (2022/23) shows 65% of households own their home, 19% are privately renting and 16% live in socially rented housing.

These figures are similar in Wales based on the 2021 census, where 66.4% of households own their homes and 33.6% rent, and in Northern Ireland, where 65.2% of households own their home and 34.8% rent. In Scotland, 58% of dwellings are owner-occupied and 38% of dwellings are rented (based on 2020 figures).

If we multiply the average household size in England with the number of households that own or rent, according to the 2021 census, it appears that roughly 32.6 million people own their home, and 19.9 million are renting.

The picture in London seems different. More households in London rent than own their homes. 31% were private renters in 2022/23, and 21% social renters, while 49% owned their home. While in the rest of England, excluding London, home ownership in England was 68%. 

We’ve contacted Mr Tweneboa for comment and will update this article if he responds.

On BBC Radio 4’s Today programme this morning, presenter Nick Robinson suggested the forthcoming by-election for the Rochdale constituency was caused by the “expulsion” from Labour of MP Simon Danzcuk 

During a segment on Labour withdrawing support for its Rochdale candidate Azhar Ali over comments he is alleged to have made about Israel, Mr Robinson said [starts at 2:12:20] there were now three men “rejected” by Labour challenging the seat, including: "The MP whose expulsion by Labour led to the by-election, Simon Danczuk, now running for Reform.”

However, this isn’t right. The by-election on 29 February is actually being held following the death of the incumbent Labour MP Sir Tony Lloyd on 17 January days after announcing he had an incurable form of leukaemia. 

Mr Danczuk was the MP for Rochdale from 2010 to 2017, but was suspended by the Labour party in 2015 after newspaper allegations about his private life. At the time, he apologised “unreservedly” for what he described as “inappropriate” behaviour in a post on X (formerly Twitter). 

Mr Danczuk was not allowed by Labour to stand as its candidate in the 2017 general election and stood as an independent. Sir Tony, who had formerly represented the Stretford and Manchester Central constituencies and served as the Greater Manchester Police and Crime Commissioner, won the seat for Labour.

Mr Danczuk is now contesting the seat as the candidate for the Reform UK party.

There are 11 candidates standing to be Rochdale’s next MP.

We’ve contacted the BBC about this and will update this post if we hear back.

In recent weeks we’ve seen two Labour MPs, including deputy leader Angela Rayner, claim that a think tank found that “on average, people are over £10,000 a year worse off” after 14 years of Conservative government.

This isn’t what the Centre for Cities study they referenced says, however. The figure in question is actually a cumulative estimate for the period between 2010 and 2022—the estimate wasn’t over £10,000 “a year”. 

It’s also worth noting it was a counterfactual estimate, comparing the present to an alternative scenario, so doesn’t show how much less income the average person actually has compared to 2010. 

For more details, see the full fact check of this claim which we’ve published today.

An interview with chief secretary to the Treasury Laura Trott MP yesterday caused confusion after she appeared to disagree with BBC Radio 4’s PM presenter Evan Davis’ claim that debt would be higher in five years time than it is now.

And the fallout from the interview has continued today, with Ms Trott trending on X (formerly Twitter) and widespread media coverage of the exchange. 

Figures published in November by the Office for Budget Responsibility (OBR) show that underlying debt as a percentage of Gross Domestic Product (GDP) is forecast to be 89.0% this financial year (2023/24), and 92.8% in five years time (2028/29)—so 3.8 percentage points higher. 

Underlying debt is the measure the government uses in its fiscal rules, which state that underlying debt must be falling as a percentage of GDP between the fourth and fifth year of the forecast period. It excludes the Bank of England’s debt.

Mr Davis quoted these figures multiple times in the interview, but Ms Trott appeared to repeatedly suggest debt was not rising “as a percentage of GDP”.

It’s possible that some confusion may have arisen from the fact that Ms Trott was initially referring to the fiscal rules mentioned above, while Mr Davis seems to have been referring to whether debt would be higher at the end of the forecast period than it is currently.

As was noted in the interview, OBR figures do show that underlying debt is forecast to begin falling at the end of the period—peaking at 93.2% in 2027/28 before falling to 92.8% the following year.

This means that the government is currently forecast to be meeting its fiscal target, even though debt will be higher in five years’ time than it is currently.

We’ve written a full fact check about the exchange, which you can read here.

In the last couple of weeks we’ve looked into two claims published in a document outlining the Labour party’s five “national missions”, reportedly the party’s election “campaigning bible”.

On 26 January, we checked a claim that there have been “4,000 GPs cut” under the Conservative government. 

Labour hasn’t responded to our questions about this claim, but this figure is unreliable, because Labour appear to have reached it by comparing the current data with a different, non-comparable dataset from before 2015.

If you date the current period of Conservative government from 2015, when the party won a majority in the House of Commons, then the number of fully qualified GPs has fallen by nearly 2,000—although the total including those in training has risen by about 3,000.

There appears to be no reliable way to compare with the number of GPs doing NHS work earlier than that—for example, with 2010, when the whole period of Conservative-led government began—because NHS Digital changed the way it counts GP numbers in 2015.

Labour’s document also said there are “2.98 million people now using food banks, up from 60,000 in 2010”—a claim we’ve also seen made elsewhere.

The Trussell Trust—the largest food bank network in the UK—confirmed to Full Fact that these figures show the number of emergency food parcels it distributed in 2022/23 and 2010/11, not the number of individual people using food banks. That means they could double-count people who use a food bank more than once, and also fail to count people who use food banks which aren’t run by the Trussell Trust.

We’ve not been able to find a reliable estimate for the number of people using food banks currently. Data published by the government suggests that in the 2021/22 financial year approximately two million people lived in a household where a food bank has been used—however use has clearly increased substantially in recent years, with 760,000 people accessing Trussell Trust food banks for the first time in 2022/23.

Rishi Sunak’s admission that the government has failed on a pledge to cut NHS waiting lists in England is widely covered this morning—and a common error cropped up again in a chart in the Guardian’s write-up, which has since been corrected.

The chart’s headline said it showed that “more than 7.6m NHS patients in England were awaiting treatment in November”.

In fact, as you can see from a chart of our own in a recent fact check, about 6.4 million patients were estimated to be waiting for non-emergency treatment with NHS England at the end of November.

But between them, these people were awaiting treatment in about 7.6 million cases. There are more cases than patients on the waiting list, because some people are waiting to be treated for more than one thing. 

It’s been common to talk about patients instead of cases for a long time, but it was hard to say how misleading this was until NHS England began publishing an estimate for the number of patients last year.

Now that we have a correct number, we think it’s important that people in politics and the media should use it, so we’ve checked several claims like this recently.

After we contacted the Guardian about the error, the chart’s headline was corrected to say “more than 7.6m NHS cases in England were awaiting treatment in November”.

On Times Radio this morning, Labour’s shadow economic secretary to the Treasury, Tulip Siddiq, said “the government has actually increased taxes 25 times since the last election.” 

Later, at Prime Minister’s Questions, Sir Keir Starmer appeared to add to the list. He said Rishi Sunak had “told every council in the country to put their council tax up by the maximum of 5%”, adding “that’s 26 tax rises now”.

These are variations of a claim we’ve heard regularly from Labour in recent months. We wrote about it last week.  

Full Fact obtained what appears to be the list of the 25 tax rises, but we don’t know why Labour selected these specific measures for inclusion. The Institute for Fiscal Studies has said there have likely been hundreds of revenue-raising tax changes (as well as cuts) taking effect since 2019.

With the government’s Safety of Rwanda Bill continuing its passage in the House of Lords today, Full Fact looked into a claim that other countries were seeking to copy the UK’s plan to process asylum claims in a third country. 

Earlier this month a headline in the HuffPost claimed that “a surprisingly large number of countries have copied [the] UK's Rwanda plan.”

This is not quite right. Although the countries mentioned in the article—Austria, Italy, Germany and Denmark—have explored the option of using a third country for processing asylum seekers with a view to determining their right to move to those countries, the UK’s proposed Rwanda scheme goes further than this, as it removes asylum seekers’ rights to seek asylum in the UK. 

The HuffPost article also mentions the Emergency Transit System which removes asylum seekers from Libya and transports them to Rwanda. This scheme is funded by the EU and is very different to the proposals being put forward by the UK.

Full Fact contacted the HuffPost and the headline of the article has since been amended to say that some other countries “could copy” the UK scheme. We are grateful to the HuffPost for making this change.