A photo shows a hospitalised woman who was found stabbed by a canal in Bradford on the night of 18 February.
False. This is an old photo showing a woman who was injured in a car accident in South Australia in 2017, and West Yorkshire Police told Full Fact this is a hoax post.
A photo shows a hospitalised woman who was found stabbed by a canal in Honiton on the night of 19 February.
This isn’t true. Devon and Cornwall Police said there’d been no such incident in Honiton. The photo shows a woman who was hospitalised in Los Angeles in June 2024.
Facebook posts claim to show photos of hospitalised women who were supposedly found stabbed in Bradford, West Yorkshire, and Honiton, Devon, recently. But the photos shared are from other incidents in the US, and the relevant local police forces have confirmed the claims aren’t genuine.
One post was shared in a Facebook community group for Bradford and West Yorkshire on 19 February, and said: “We need urgent assistance in identifying this woman found last night heavily stabbed multiple times and dumped in her Black Audi A7 sedan by the canal here in #bradford She's in critical condition and missing her ID's/ Drivers Licence, No phone, No nothing Let’s flood our feeds so that this post reaches her family. Thank you [sic]”.
The post includes a photo of a woman lying in a hospital bed, with what appears to be a breathing tube and various monitoring wires, but she was not found stabbed in Bradford on 18 February. The picture was shared in a 2019 video report by Australian outlet 9News about the recovery of a 23-year-old woman who was severely injured in a car accident in South Australia in 2017.
West Yorkshire Police have confirmed this Facebook post is a hoax.
An almost identical post was shared on 20 February, this time claiming a woman was found in Honiton, Devon. This post used a different photo of another hospitalised woman. But again, this is an old photo. The image used actually shows a woman who was a patient at Los Angeles General Medical Center in June 2024, whose identity the hospital was appealing for information on. Devon and Cornwall Police told Full Fact that they have no record of any such a stabbing happening in Honiton.
Another sign that these are not genuine posts is that their comment sections have been turned off, which Derbyshire Police Online Safety team has previously said is a sign of a hoax.
Both posts also include a second photo that appears to show a car being pulled from a body of water while emergency service workers look on. This photo comes from reports of a recent incident in West Palm Beach in Florida, US, when the body of a missing woman, Denise Cosme, was found in her car after it was located in a canal.
We’ve written before about similar posts falsely raising the alarm for missing children, elderly people, abandoned infants and injured dogs in Facebook community groups.
Our investigation into these types of hoax posts found they’re often edited later to include links to surveys, freebies or cheap housing—you can find out more by watching an episode of BBC’s Rip Off Britain in which our investigation is featured. Our guide also offers some tips on how to identify such hoaxes.
This behaviour poses a risk to user engagement with local community groups, which can become overwhelmed with false information. We’ve written to Facebook’s parent company Meta expressing concerns about how these hoax posts can flood community groups, and asking the company to take stronger action in response to this problem.
This article is part of our work fact checking potentially false pictures, videos and stories on Facebook. You can read more about this—and find out how to report Facebook content—here. For the purposes of that scheme, we’ve rated this claim as false because these photos do not show women who were recently found stabbed in Bradford or Honiton.
Full Fact fights for good, reliable information in the media, online, and in politics.
Bad information ruins lives. It promotes hate, damages people’s health, and hurts democracy. You deserve better.